Tip #9 - Fleece vs Fleece

Tip #9 - Fleece vs Fleece

Before we get started let's meet our contenders. In the blue corner with the high collar and 100% eco design is the Quechua Forclaz 50. In the red corner featuring two zippered pockets and a full frontal zipper is Quechua's Forclaz 200.


So is the Forclaz 50 the optimum choice for Rs. 599 or does the Forclaz 200 have features that justify its price of Rs. 999 and make it better value for money?

inditramp answers - Forclaz 50 for trekking and Forclaz 200 for camping


Before we explain our choice and the differences between the contenders let us look at the similarities

  • Both fleeces are rated for a temperature range between 7°C and 10°C

  • Both are made with the same material (100% polyester PES) and have the same volume (200g/sqm)

  • Both are breathable with a Polyester knit that lets through water vapour generated by the body (RET=7.08)

  • Both fleece won't crease, are easy to machine wash and dry quick.


Quechua Forclaz 50

  • Lightweight at 286g in size L

  • The high collar is no gimmick, it has kept our neck snug while sleeping and in early mornings and late evenings.

  • The half zip helps vent perspiration and we have not had the need for a full zip while trekking. The problem with a full zip is that you cannot undo it completely with a backpack on. The sternum and waist straps get in the way

  • The same holds for side pockets on the Forclaz 200. We found them to be inaccessible with a backpack waist strap on. We would have loved a chest pocket like the one on Decathlon's Forclaz 500. The chest pocket is the best place for a mobile / GPS as it is accessible with a backpack on and it keeps the batteries from draining in the cold.

  • Made from 100% recycled polyester thread, reducing its environmental impact. If you care for recycling like we do, it is an important plus point.

Quechua Forclaz 200

  • The situation reverses while out camping, the zippered side pockets become the perfect repository for cold hands or for carrying knick knacks around camp.

  • The full zipper is more comfortable and practical when sitting around a campfire.

  • Heavier by 17% (348g in size L)

  • Decathlon does not mention if this fleece uses 100% recycled polyester thread. We're assuming it doesn't.

We tested both the Forclaz 50 and 200 for a month in over 8 treks from elevations ranging from 1800 metres to 3400 metres in Garhwal Himalaya. Let us know what you think about our choice in the comments below. If you're interested in more such tips head on to our Tips category.

George Everest House to Tibetan Hill - The Garhwal Himalaya view trail

George Everest House to Tibetan Hill - The Garhwal Himalaya view trail

Lal Tibba to Kolti Village Day Trek - A trek in pictures

Lal Tibba to Kolti Village Day Trek - A trek in pictures